How do I know a roof needs replacing rather than repair?
Replacement is usually the answer when damage is spread over several slopes, shingles are brittle or bare, or the roof has already been repaired repeatedly. A roofer who inspects the deck and attic can tell you; ask for a written reason, and compare it against the cost of repair.
A single storm can total a roof or leave it fine. The question is whether the system as a whole still works. If most shingles lift cleanly, if the decking is sound and if only a few areas are damaged, repair may be the sensible call. See roof repair if that is where yours falls.
On older roofs, a good roofer will explain what the tear-off will probably show. You are not committing to anything by asking.
What does the permit process look like in Souderton?
Souderton Borough says the Borough Code of Ordinances and the Pennsylvania Uniform Construction Code control building permits, that you apply at the borough office, and that no work starts without an approved permit. Other townships may differ, so check with the one your house is in.
Do not assume a roofer will handle it unless they say so. Ask who applies, who pays any fee, and what happens if an inspection is needed. This page states no fee, because no sourced figure exists.
The roofing permits guide goes through the questions. A different borough or township, such as Doylestown Borough, may have its own contractor page or requirement.
Why does the deck matter so much?
The deck, the wood sheathing under the shingles, holds the nails and carries the roof. Rot or old splits can let new shingles loosen early. The roofer should check it at tear-off, replace damaged boards and tell you what was replaced.
On older housing the deck may have been patched or re-nailed over the decades. Whatever the construction, the roofer should keep the decking dry, replace what is unsound and not roof over a problem.
If you can, ask to see the replaced boards, and ask how many were swapped and at what rate. A written line for decking in the proposal avoids an argument later.
How long does a replacement take?
How long a replacement takes depends on roof size, complexity, deck repairs and weather, and no timeframe can be promised from here. The roofer sets the schedule once they have looked at the roof and know when a crew is free. Ask for their estimate in writing.
Rain delays everything, and the roofer will not want an open deck in a storm. See the replacement timeline guide for what the stages are and where delays come from.